October 29:
“If national life becomes so perfect as to become self-regulated, no representation becomes necessary.”
–Gandhi (Young India, July 2, 1931)
Gandhi’s ideal political system? Two words: Enlightened anarchy. (If you are like me, you will need a minute to take that in. But hold on to your seat, because it gets better…) It really shouldn’t be too big of a surprise to us, though, if you think about his insistence upon swaraj, or freedom. When he talked about it, he was talking about more than just freedom from the British Raj through self-sufficiency and economic independence; he was talking about a society where each person had enough discrimination, nonviolent discipline and self-restraint to be able to look as deeply inward at themselves as they look out to the world in which they wish to live. He puts it this way: “In such a state, every one is his or her own ruler,” and then he goes on to say, “In the ideal State, therefore, there is no political power because there is no State.” This is getting good. And then he adds, just to whet our appetites even more, that in such a state where “the power is generated from within” there wouldn’t be any need for police and military. I’m in. But then he comes back to Earth a bit and reminds us that this kind of a state is an ideal, like perfect ahimsa. As with ideals, all we can do is strive toward them and that struggle is worth every ounce of energy we give it. The way forward then? Develop the mindset of personal swaraj; in other words, develop these qualities within ourselves. As we often say around the Metta Center, nonviolence or “the revolution” is not about putting the right kind of person in power, it’s about awakening the right kind of power in people. Like you and me.
Experiment in Nonviolence:
What is your most ideal vision of the State? How does it overlap with Gandhi’s vision?
Do you know of other people in or near Newark, DE who subscribe to the Daily Metta and might want to meet to talk about the daily exercise? This, of course, is to affirm these wonderful daily think pieces and the practical realities.
Thank you, Stephanie. I love your last sentence.
I’ve been reading “A Paradise Built in Hell” by Rebecca Solnit, who writes at length about widespread and longlasting fears of leaders that people will become dangerous to themselves and others in the aftermath of a disaster are in direct contrast to how we actually behave. In actuality, there is a great deal of sharing, cooperation, and support at all levels of society and a comaraderie that reaches across those levels as well.
Here’s one paragraph quoting American sociologist Charles E. Fritz, whom Solnit describes as one who “began the little-known and remarkable field of disaster studies.” Now the quotation from Fritz: “The widespread sharing of danger, loss, and deprivation produces and intimate, primarily group solidarity among the survivors, which overcomes social isolation, provides a major source of physical and emotional support and reassurance . . .The ‘outsider’ becomes and ‘insider,’ the ‘marginal man’ a ‘central man.’ People are thus able to perceive, with a clarity never before possible, as set of underlying basic values to be maintained and the individual and group goals are inextricably merged. This merging of individual and societal needs provides a feeling of belonging and a sense of unity rarely achieved under
normal circumstance.”
Indeed, Solnit describes a kind of joy that people report feeling in the aftermath of a disaster. She documents this repeatedly in reports from people around the world who have experienced many different types of disaster. My own daughter reported this after the Loma Prieta earthquake
in San Francisco.
Much to think about and learn from.
Hi Nancy, I’ll be in touch about this. It’s a great idea and I bet others would be interested. For the new year, I was contemplating how to do this…
Maybe I’ll send out a message to the whole DM list to get input.
Warmly, Stephanie
That’s a very insightful remark from Fritz. Thank you for sharing it. I agree, it adds to the banquet for thought!